Wet n Wild, H2O Proof Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof and Stain-proof Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof Makeup, Long-lasting, Fluid and Pigmented Formula, Black

The product is pretty good - especially for the cost. The liquid itself is good and lasts. My only disappointment is the brush...it is not quite as brush-like as I would expect and would have liked (I expected a flexible brush made of hair/fibres) but it is more like a flexible stick and only a little bit flexible at the end. Getting used to it - but prefer a proper brush. But overall, good value and satisfied with purchase.

Nice a small went on easy lasted all day smudge proof what more can a girl/,guy want

This US-made product has been tricky to get hold of up to now in the UK but now the packaging states there's a UK-based distributor, I'm hoping it will be much easier. If you've previously bought Wet & Wild H2O Proof in the silver/blue box in 'Ultra Black', rest assured this appears to be the same product in updated packaging. The one difference I can see is that the felt tip applicator is even finer - but very easy to apply broader strokes or build 'wings' if you want to. If you've not used H2O Proof before - wow, buy this and you're on the brink of discovering the BEST eyeliner on the market today at any price! It is intensely black and long-lasting, doesn't fade and it's easy to apply without any dragging on lids. It should stay on through heavy rain, tears, sweat etc and a bottle lasts for many weeks if you wear the product daily - no touch-ups required - so along with the great price it's truly good value. It can be a little hard to take off. At present I'm using a tiny dab of silicone-based primer as the grease seems to break down the formula but this is expensive so I may try micellar water which another reviewer has suggested. However, let's face it, the usual problem with eyeliner is keeping it on! Try H2O Proof - you won't regret it.

It soon smudged

Love this liner. Easy application with the narrow tip. Doesn't get clunky. Being waterproof it's great for inner eye lining. Lasts on until cleaned with make-up remover. Great product

Ideally do not buy this!Wore this a couple times whilst working at a school and everyday, I’d end up leaving with black eyelids and under eyes.Extremely hard to take off with micellar water too - gone back to more expensive brand.

I am giving the BRUSH a good review - it's a great brush - I use it with a different eye liner - unfortunately the liquid in this stuff is hands down THE WORST liquid liner I have EVER used. Whilst I was out with my in laws I had to get a mirror out every 20 minutes ALL DAY and wipe away the liner that had just smudged (without being touched) and transferred onto my upper eye lid - it was awful. I've never experienced such a thing before.If give it -5 stars if it wasn't for the brush that I now use to do liner art on the corners of my eye - with a proper waterproof liner.

I like it, the tip is thin and easy to apply, the formula isn't too thick in my opinion however its not COMPLETELY waterproof but it does a good job